Showing posts with label climate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate. Show all posts

Monday, September 22, 2014

Many steps and many voices

Yesterday's People's Climate March in New York City succeeded in at least part of what it set out to do. Early estimates have the turnout at 310,000 people (and it could climb to 400,000 after final analysis) in NYC alone...not counting the dozens of sympathy marches taking place everywhere from England and Australia to Oklahoma City. Those who challenged the event to relevancy had their challenge met and exceeded. At least some of those who might have some say in the outcome...Bill de Blasio, Ban Ki-moon...attended, giving even more hope to those that attended.

AP/Jason DeCrow

Only time will tell if it made even the slightest bit of a difference.

In 1963, approximately 250,000 marched on Washington to demand  peaceful and political solution to the civil rights atrocities that institutionalized people of color as second class citizens in this country...the land of freedom and equality. Half a century later, despite achieving short-term political solutions, the dreams given voice that day still have yet to fully materialize. The voices of those opposed to ceding any economic or political power still have control, albeit much more subversively than they did fifty years ago.

In time, however, those voices will - quite literally - die out. It's hollow solace for those who still have to work twice as hard to achieve half as much, but their children will live to see an equal country.

On the issue of fossil fuels, the pollution it causes, and the impact on human life, we do not have that kind of time, and we face a similar, less subtle foe. A search of the hashtag #climatemarch yesterday in the hours that followed the event found both hopeful messages of those who attended or wished they did as well as a healthy mix of trolls* providing counter point to the issue of climate protection. Although we can casually brush off that kind of rhetoric as uncivilized, uneducated, or even irrelevant, one crucial point remains.

The opposition to acting on climate is real, well-funded, and poignant.

Among the schoolyard name calling and pictures of Nicholas Cage, one can find some valid criticism of the climate movement that we need to address if not directly, then at least obliquely. First and foremost, we need to get better at focusing on the issue at hand and not the hyperbolic predictions. Talking about the dangers of sea-level rise, then having to admit they will happen over a hundred years into the future blunts the argument. People believe in the innovative spirit, and trust that that spirit will solve a problem that long into the future. Our aims must focus on much more immediate threats.

Second, tying onto that thought, we need to exercise caution about how far we reach. The science surrounding drought and extreme storms has only just begun to investigate the role that greenhouse gas emissions play. To blame climate change for the California drought, Sandy, and the polar vortex makes for great headlines, but it smacks of the same pseudo-science that fills the counter arguments. Also, it sets up deniers to make similar claims when the US experiences one of the coldest winters on record. We have so many issues with immediate impact: The dangers of mining, the damage to countrysides and water resources, air pollution...we do not need to grasp opportunistically for every straw that comes our way.

Third, we need to get away from arguments that cost more. I personally know that morality tells us to prioritize the lives of people near fossil fuel extraction fields or thermal plants, or those who live in endangered island nations. But I also know that imposing morality on another creates confrontation not solutions. This gets especially true when every argument for solutions ends up recommending solutions that cost more than current options. We need to put our human ingenuity to work and create solutions that cost less. Economic analyses are starting to make the argument that a clean energy future will save us money...blunting any argument for including fossil fuels in any new energy plant. We need to focus on that future, and the dwindling availability of fossil fuels in a world with expanding population and increased development. (In fifty years - a time horizon that people can connect with since most of us expect to live that long, we could be almost out of fossil fuels. The reserves that industry themselves admit to being available, coupled with the current rate of increase in exploitable reserves, still does not match the rate of consumption we will experience over the next half-century.) That means increased prices and decreased quality of life unless we respond. That's a story that people can connect to as we have experienced several such shocks in the past decades.

Lastly, and yesterday's march rightly starts this discussion, we need to focus on the clean energy fight as one of innovation and equality. Amidst the recent public discussions of marriage equality, several conservative pundits noted that they heard a compelling argument on behalf of those seeking the right to marry, and no counter argument to the idea of free choice. We need to have the same focus in the fight on climate. Emissions of any sort provide an opportunity to make sure that prices for sources of energy include all costs associated with each source. If we frame the argument in terms of our communal desire for freedom and a fair market, clean energy wins each time. The more we focus on common themes, the larger a tent we create and the greater our chance of success.

In many ways, the climate march was the art of the possible. The economics favor systems that use less energy, and at every juncture over the past decade, when faced with a challenge to reduce energy use while preserving quality of life, we have succeeded (eg. cutting refrigerator energy use by more than half, increasing fuel efficiency in cars, improving the energy efficiency of buildings). We no longer need to act like a fringe movement nipping at the heels of industry. The growing industries are on our side, and all we need to do is remain consistent and the economics will continue to favor the cause of pollution reduction. If we keep clouding the issue with ideas that do not resonate, and even worse give fuel to opposition, we threaten all the hard work. The next steps forward need to be ones of community...solutions that work for all.

That even includes the trolls.


*trolling is an internet term for those who seek to create discord by playing devil's advocate and saying whatever they can to get a rise out of people.

Friday, August 29, 2014

Friday Five: August 29, 2014

Our driving mantra in everything we do should be quality of life. If we improve quality of life, we will actually reduce population, decrease stress on resources, and avoid environmental catastrophe. Win/win/win/....
How can we stop the world from having too many babies? Feed more people
"We can make the pie bigger through scientific advances — increasing farm yields and finding more efficient sources of energy. We can reduce the number of forks with family-planning programs, providing access to contraception and giving women more power over their bodies and finances. We can promote better table manners, that is, more equitable sharing, through, well, either more government or less. 'The "better manners" school calls for freer markets or socialism (depending on taste),' Cohen writes."

The plastic bag is actually a marvel of design. It easily carries far more than it's weight, and stores easily. Trouble is, we had a couple other "marvels of design" in the past: asbestos, lead in paint and gasoline...sometimes the elegant solution masks the dangers. I am sure the asbestos industry was not happy when it was banned, but we are the better for it.
Banning the plastic bag shouldn't be this hard
"The opponents of the bill — mainly, bag makers — have said it would be a job killer, even though the legislation includes $2 million to help manufacturers transition to making thicker, reusable plastic bags ... A third of Californians, including shoppers in the city of Los Angeles, live in communities that have eliminated single-use plastic bags, and there has been little blowback to the bans."

It's really simple folks: do nothing, and if we were right - we are doomed...do something, and if we were wrong we get cleaner air, more reliable energy, and better quality of life. It's not that hard.
U.N. draft report lists unchecked emissions' risks
"The new report found that it was still technically possible to limit global warming to an internationally agreed upper bound of 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit, or 2 degrees Celsius, above the preindustrial level. But continued political delays for another decade or two will make that unachievable without severe economic disruption, the report said."

Should I be scared when a bank agrees with me? Maybe they've been reading my blog.
UBS analysts: 'Large-scale power stations could be on path to extinction'
"UBS contends that centralized fossil-fuel generation will become “extinct” -- and that it will happen a lot sooner than most people realize.
The bank predicts that a significant number of large-scale centralized plants could be gone within a decade. 'Not all of them will have disappeared by 2025, but we would be bold enough to say that most of those plants retiring in the future will not be replaced.'"

You read right....MINNESOTA!
Power surge in Minnesota's solar industry
"The year-old solar array in Slayton, Minn., the size of eight football fields, could soon lose its mantle as Minnesota’s largest. Its output is 2 megawatts, or 2 million watts. Now, projects five times that size are planned. One project proposed by Geronimo Energy in Chisago County is rated at 50 megawatts, enough to power about 6,000 homes and an output equivalent to a small natural gas power plant. Minneapolis-based Xcel is considering several 'utility-scale' projects whose size offers economies of scale. 'The prices appear to be competitive,' said Dave Sparby, Xcel’s chief executive for the Minnesota region."

Happy Friday!

David Brewster/Star Tribune

Monday, June 2, 2014

Carbon rules are coming...and they will be easy to meet

Today, the President Obama and the EPA – bolstered by recent court rulings - will announce rules for carbon dioxide emissions targets.  Reports vary from 20% reduction by 2020 to a 30% reduction by 2030.  Regardless of the actual target chosen, we should all remember one thing…

We will beat that target easily.

Politics, we should all remember, has as its foundation the “art of the possible”.  Most everyone in industry, except for those whose commodities will have less value because of reduced demand for carbon-based fuels, recognizes that energy efficiency and renewable energy have a better economic trajectory than fossil fuels or even nuclear.  In setting this goal, the current administration simply identifies where industry easily thinks they can get.  Just as they did with the automobile efficiency standards, they have put in place a benchmark that we will meet far before the target date.

Lest pure political analysis prove unpersuasive, consider the economic argument.  For years, analysts claimed that we needed to tax fossil fuels in order to capture externalities and make renewable energy more competitive.  What we got instead was an energy market that remained depressed by a combination of stagnant demand and temporarily increased supply.  That should have spelled a death knell for renewable energy.  Instead, we have seen wind and solar have their most successful years economically in a time when low energy prices should push them out of the market.  Recent long-term contracts and court rulings in the Midwest have bolstered this fact that even as of today, renewable energy-based electricity generation betters coal and nuclear, and competes with natural gas.

On the technology front, current building codes currently restrict energy use in new buildings to levels about half of what they were a decade ago.  Over the next ten years, we will see this decline even further, and that will carry over into the existing building marketplace.  We will see even more efficient use of energy in buildings (a sector that uses about 1/3 of the energy in the economy), and continued reduction in vehicle emissions.  Industrial use (the final 1/3) already has stagnated as industry continues to find excellent investments in efficient ways to update equipment and processes to use less energy.  Our economic growth no longer relies on increased energy use, and in fact, we may see the opposite hold true for decades to come.

On an even more important front, most politicians recognize that energy efficiency and renewable energy technologies create more jobs per dollar than the fossil fuel industry.  Few groups take the “sky is falling” approach to carbon regulation, but the some continue to flap their wings and claim that regulating carbon will cause economic collapse.  Thankfully, most recognize that pollution limits actually create jobs by shifting capital (human and financial) from extractive industry to productive ones.  Spending money on new wind turbines, smart-grid technology, weatherization of homes, or pollution capture technology…these all put people to work and shift expenses from one sector to another, but it does not threaten the economy as a whole.

One need look no further than the acid rain policies of the 80s and 90s to see a parallel.  Back then we sought to reduce sulfur and nitrogen oxide emissions from power plants because these reacted with the atmosphere to produce rain that damaged crops, buildings, and communities.  Industry predicted it would create a $1,500 per ton drag on the economy.  What happened instead was that it cost only $250 per ton, and the savings from increased property value, reduced medical expenses, and job creation more than paid for the investment.

For years, we have had to choose between the more economically stable sector and the higher-priced, but better-for-us sector.  Especially in tough economic times, asking anyone to make that choice is tough.  Now, we have reached a tipping point where we do not have to sacrifice anyone’s quality of life in order to cost-effectively provide the energy that supports our lives.  Challenges lie ahead, but we should take solace in the fact that the Obama administration is taking this step today.  If there’s one thing we know about politicians….


They rarely stick their necks out unless they’re certain of the outcome.

Friday, May 9, 2014

Friday Five: May 9, 2014

The recent National Climate Assessment contains warnings not of impending issues, but rather concerns that some of the major causes of climate change are already upon us.
Climate change is already causing asthma. Cancer too.
"The National Climate Assessment, which hundreds of scientists helped put together, warns that the effects of global warming aren’t some far-off possibility. They are happening right now, here in the U.S. Those effects include all the familiar problems: drought, wildfires, extreme weather, and sea level rise. But they include something else: Threats to public health."

In addition to the direct health concerns, we will have to adjust the way and location in which we grow the crops that underpin our sustenance and our economy.
Our alarming food future explained in 7 charts
"Richard Cruse, an agronomist and the director of Iowa State University’s Iowa Water Center, has found Iowa’s soils are currently disappearing at a rate as much as 16 times faster than the natural regeneration. According to the National Assessment, days of heavy rain have increased steadily in Iowa over the past two decades, and will continue doing so."

We continue to learn that nuclear and natural gas are not the "bridging fuels" we once thought them to be, and that we would find a more cost-effective plan would focus only on efficiency and renewables.
The rising cost of decommissioning a nuclear power plant
"The Yankee Nuclear Power Station in Rowe, Massachusetts, took 15 years to decommission—or five times longer than was needed to build it. And decommissioning the plant—constructed early in the 1960s for $39 million—cost $608 million. The plant’s spent fuel rods are still stored in a facility on-site, because there is no permanent disposal repository to put them in. To monitor them and make sure the material does not fall into the hands of terrorists or spill into the nearby river costs $8 million per year. That cost will continue for an unknown number of years. David Lochbaum of the Union of Concerned Scientists estimates that even without the ongoing costs of monitoring and security, the average reactor now costs about $500 million to deactivate."

New technology can offer a potential way to mitigate some of the water issues we face due both to climate change and to inherent challenges due to consumption.
UCLA researchers unveil a better way to treat brackish water
"The system treats water at a cost of about $1.50 per 1,000 liters, said Cohen, who has installed desalination technology on U.S. military vessels. By way of comparison, bottled water costs about $1 to $3 per liter."

In the information economy, we no longer need to hold onto outdated and extractive business models, but can use information to link local businesses in a way that taps into the power of aggregated risk management while preserving the personal relationships that truly define a society.
The socio-economic power of renewable energy production cooperatives in Germany
"Energy cooperatives have turned into important supporters of renewable and decentralised energy structures, due to their strong growth since the year 2006, their participation in local renewable energy projects and their democratic awareness. The cooperative form of coordinating local renewable energy projects applies to a decentralised energy system that is managed by many smaller firms - a system concept that is preferred by the majority of German citizens. However, there is not enough knowledge to understand to what extent this organisational form is able to unify a broad group of actors in promoting a renewable energy system (societal power) and to gather capital for elaborating renewable energy supply structures (economic power)."

Happy Friday!



Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Flashes: May 7, 2014

Stanford's divestment of coal seems like a groundbreaking environmental moment until you realize Goldman Sachs' long-term outlook for coal is bleak.

Mitch McConnell says carbon hypocrites should stop using climate change as a political tool.  By that logic, does that mean rich politicians will stop pretending they know about poverty?

Originally, we couldn't switch to renewables because they cost more.  Now they cost the same.
But now we can't switch because they are intermittent.  Except, this past winter proved conventionals are intermittent.
Now we have to make whole those who have invested in sunk, fossil fuel technologies before we can move forward?
When did the energy field move from capitalism to socialism?

I love the Jon Stewart commentary on government picking winners and losers:  (paraphrase)
"You say the government should not be in the business of picking winners and losers, they should be focusing on building roads, rails and bridges....except that's the government picking winners and losers!  That's the government picking cars, trucks and trains over other modes of transportation."

Enjoy the journey!


Monday, March 10, 2014

You want jobs? Efficiency not mining

Over the next several weeks, the media will cover ad nauseum President Obama's decision on the Keystone XL pipeline that developers plan to run through the upper Midwest to connect the tar sands mining operations of Canada with the Gulf Coast export terminals of Texas.  Ignoring for now the potential cost in human life due to increased emissions of carbon soot and carbon dioxide, the increased risk to drinking water and arable land from pipeline breaks (which happen regularly), and the increased environmental damage to the Gulf Coast region where the tar sands refining operations will take place, the pipeline makes no sense from the point of view of a financial investment.  Depending on the source, the pipeline plans to create between 1,000 and 5,000 temporary jobs, 50 and 1,000 permanent jobs, and potentially influence the development of as many as 20,000 jobs.  It will cost at least $5.3 billion, and none of the fuel produced from the delivery and refining processes will go to support American machinery...it will all go to a burgeoning Latin American market.  This pipeline represents profits for the corporation that owns it, not energy independence for the US or Canada.  The jobs created by the investment - even if they happen at the highest level imagined - do not justify the expense, and we have much better ways to invest the capital.

For the sake of analysis, I consider a temporary job to have the value of one-tenth that of a permanent job; this assumes that a permanent job will last on the order of ten years, and the temporary job around a year.  This puts the range of direct, combined jobs at somewhere between 150 and 1,500.  At an investment of $5.3 billion, the investment-to-job ratio sits at around $35 million to $3.5 million per job.

The best alternative to the Keystone XL pipeline, energy efficiency investments, not only avoid all the human health problems KXL will cause, but it also creates more - and better - jobs.  Two recent energy efficiency programs serve as a basis for this argument.  The Energy Impact Illinois (EI2) program used ARRA money to match utility incentive program and private homeowner contributions to winterize homes and reduce the demand for heating energy.  In the US Southeast, ARRA funds also contributed to the Better Building Neighborhood Program (BBNP) which operated in the same fashion.  For each of these programs, the investment-to-jobs ratio looks like this:

Program                    Investment                      Jobs created                      Ratio         
EI2                               $24.0M                              140                          $171,428/job
BBMP                          $37.9M                              350                          $108,285/job

For an investment in energy efficiency on the scale of Keystone XL, the $5.3 billion investment would mean somewhere between 30,000 and 50,000 permanent jobs.  With a simple return on investment (ROI) somewhere in the 10-50% range for the direct savings (reduced utility costs), and a multiplier effect resulting in an ROI of up to 375% regionally from the boost to jobs and economic growth.

For decades, many have argued against investments in renewable energy and energy efficiency because they "cost too much".  This argument had merit on the renewable energy side when new technologies had no scale or access to market, and on the energy efficiency side when energy costs remained artificially low due to market manipulation and the absence of externalities (like the additional healthcare costs and property damage that results from burning fossil fuels).  The charge that clean energy costs too much no longer holds water.  Investments in energy efficiency bring greater ROI than investments in fossil fuels, and result in hundreds of times more jobs.  In a time when we see coal plants shuttered because owners cannot afford to pay for maintenance, and power producers investing in wind over natural gas, the time is right to stop investment in fossil fuel projects that will lead to forty more years of guaranteed, high volume use of fossil fuels.  The time is right to say, "No!" to Keystone XL, and instead put that money into energy efficiency (first) then renewable energy.

Because it will put Americans back to work and make our quality of life better.  Is that not what we should expect from our economy?

Friday, March 7, 2014

Friday Five(s): March 7, 2014...Cabin Fever Edition

Through a combination of cabin-fever-inspired restlessness, and a measurable uptick in environmental news this week, I cannot bring my brain to choose only five, so I am going with a double-dose...including shorter intros by me.


This should scare the livin' bejeezus out of everyone. (And note, 'bejeezus' is recognized as a word by my autocorrect.)
Chevron launches "news" site
"Ritchie said the site also offers a new model for the future of journalism — one that is funded directly by corporations. 'We believe the website has the potential to blaze the trail for a new model of corporate-sponsored, community-generated news,' the website reads."

The market has changed, and large energy companies - and especially investor-owned utilities - face extinction if they do not find new models.
Schadenfreude about RWE unwarranted
"What should RWE do? ... Maybe we need to be open to the idea that large power corporations were needed for central-station power plants, but that their role in a renewable future will be much smaller. At the moment, even the proposal to have them leverage their size to set up an enabling infrastructure – such as charging stations for electric cars – seems unlikely. The firms don't even have the liquidity anymore."

I forgive the inappropriate use of 'global warming' in the headline because the article discusses an industry I love. I am inspired to act.
Slope & change: The ski industry struggles to get its act together on global warming
"So what, you might ask, does the ski industry lobby for in Washington, if not for climate action? In the past, it has pushed for looser immigration rules (who’ll wash all those restaurant dishes and change the hotel sheets?) and to make sure that we can continue to import cheap shred threads from China (because, you know, we’ve gotta look good out there)."

In principle, I do not have an issue with natural gas as a bridging fuel if it is employed in retrofit of existing plants, and if carbon capture is required...but until the methane leakage issue is 100% solved, natural gas is as bad as coal...period.
How to make natural gas more climate-friendly
"It doesn’t have to be this way. The technology already exists to dramatically reduce methane leakage for a reasonable price. Environmental groups have put out reports outlining how. They could serve as a template for the oil and gas industry to follow voluntarily, or for the EPA to require under the Clean Air Act."

Good consequence, incentives for industry to capture, sequester, and even mine CO2...unintended consequence without regulation, continue depleting fossil fuels as source of "high quality CO2".
Don't waste CO2, turn it into bottles and glue
"If humanity is to avoid dangerous climate change, we need to capture hundreds of billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide. But what to do with it all? There is no shortage of places to bury it, but we can at least put some of it to good use. A few start-up companies view CO2 as a resource rather than a waste product. They are using CO2 as the raw material for making products including superglue and fertilizer."

It's said that collapsing societies burned their last tree to boil their last pot of water to eat their last meal...if we are to avoid that fate, we need to examine our priorities. Maybe cultural icons will help awaken minds.
Syndey Opera House and Statue of Liberty 'will be lost to sea level rise'
"Marzeion said that in Europe, particularly vulnerable sites included the leaning tower of Pisa, which is not directly on the coast but would be affected by sea level rises as a result of even a low temperature increase because it is very low-lying. He also cited Venice, which 'in a sense you can say is being impacted right now' and Hanseatic League cities including Hamburg, Lübeck and Bremen in Germany."

If the loss of Lady Liberty doesn't move us, how about the loss of large sections of a state?
Louisiana's coastline is disappearing too quickly for mappers to keep up
"Each year, this part of the coastline loses around 16 square miles of land, according to David Muth, the state director of the National Wildlife Federation’s Mississippi River Delta Restoration Project. And until quite recently, even the most advanced maps of the area did little to reflect the changing environmental reality. But in the last few years, renewed mapping efforts from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration have begun to catalog these changes. These new maps show water where there was once marshy land, and bays where there were once small inlets."

Speaking of water, unless you live in CA or SD, you may not know how tentative our life is under "feast and famine" deluge-drought cycles.
Americans have no idea how much water we use - or how to conserve it
"Perhaps most troubling, Americans overwhelmingly believe that changing their habits, as opposed to improving the efficiency of their plumbing, is the most effective way to cut down on water consumption. Seventy-six percent of those surveyed said curtailment methods, such as flushing less frequently, are the best way to reduce water use. Only 10 percent chose more preventative measures, such as installing new toilets that use just 1.6 gallons per flush in lieu of old toilets that use five to six gallons."

Of course there is hope if we listen to free market economists and make rational decisions that are in our best economic self-interest. (Hint: That means divesting from fossil fuels and investing in clean energy & energy efficiency solutions.)
Energy efficiency creates 387% return on investment for US Southeast
"A wide range of economic benefits contributed to the overall $78.3 million in regional economic output created by SEEA’s energy efficiency upgrades. $55.7 million in economic output and 240 jobs were created through direct effects from program spending, while $22.2 million in economic output and 106 jobs were created via direct effects like efficiency goods and services. Induced effects from households or workers spending newfound money on consumer goods or services created an additional $366,471 in economic impacts."

And maybe there is something with tapping into the "keeping up with the Jones'" zeitgeist. Whatever it takes to give my grandkids a high quality of life.
With energy reports, it's game on
"But research has shown that neighbor comparisons are the most effective way to get people to conserve energy, he said. More people respond to hearing what their neighbors are doing than to the prospect of helping the environment or saving money. The comparisons work, he said; the first group of ComEd customers to get the reports, in 2009, reduced their electricity use by 2 percent."

Happy Friday!

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Daily Decisions: I can see clearly now






Throughout 2013, Adding Light will take a look at practical decisions that everyone can take to contribute to making our communities more ecologically and economically resilient. Everything in this Daily Decisions comes from experience or research applied directly by our family or people we know directly.

When my oldest was in sixth grade, she did a science project (and in our family, when we say a child did something, they did it) comparing incandescent light bulbs, compact fluorescent light (CFL) bulbs, and light-emitting diodes (LED) in terms of energy to produce the light, amount of light, and ability to read by the light.  She and her partners read a book by the light of each bulb, used a Kill-a-Watt to measure the electricity, and used a light meter to measure the light...(ok, so dad had to help in getting some of the supplies.  When it was all said and done, they came to a pretty interesting conclusion:  the compact fluorescent light worked best all around.  The incandescent light definitely had the easiest light to read by, and the LED used the least energy by far.  The bulb is no good if you cannot read using it, and the amount of energy wasted by the incandescent creates problems for others in terms of the emissions and pollution.  CFL bulbs provided high enough quality light to see by, but used about one-third the energy of incandescent bulbs (and only a little more than twice as much as the LED).  To make an immediate, and significant difference in energy usage without greatly sacrificing quality of light, we decided to make the switch to CFL bulbs for the house.

At the time (2006), luckily Home Depot had started to carry CFL bulbs in all the shapes and sizes that a house would need: flood lights, lamp-style, decorative.  Homeowners have the choice of waiting until bulbs burn out to replace them, or they can make a wholesale replacement.  The benefit of the first option comes in a more spread out cost of purchasing the bulbs; the benefit of the second comes in immediate and significant energy savings.  Neither way is wrong.  We chose wholesale replacement for all but four fixtures in the house.

The light quality changed slighting in the house, most notably when first starting the lamps, and for fixtures attached to dimming light switches.  Fluorescent bulbs for home use will usually have a warm-up period, and newer bulbs have become better acclimated to dimming switches.  For our purposes, we got used to the warm-up, and the bulbs would hum when the dimming switch was not at full power, which only required us to adjust the switch.  All in all, it was a small sacrifice for the environmental benefit.  That benefit was significant.  We lowered the peak electricity usage in our house by about twenty percent (20%), and our monthly cost by about twenty-five percent (25%).  In the time since that replacement, we have only had three out of about thirty bulbs burn out, and all three burnt out this past year (this summer will be seven years since the replacement).  CFL have lived up to their billing, delivering quality light at a significantly reduced energy usage and significantly improved environmental performance.

A description of this decision must include a couple of words of caution about the installation, care, and disposal of CFL bulbs.  These bulbs do contain mercury, which if the bulb breaks will cause a hazard for those near the bulb - a hazard similar to when we all used mercury thermometers to take our temperature.  The situation does have risks, but not unmanageable.  The EPA has a straightforward description of what to do in case of a break, and like any of our energy consuming systems, taking extra care will keep your family out of trouble.  I should note that the concern about mercury has merit, and should not be taken lightly, however it should also be extrapolated.  Much of the electricity production in the country, and especially the Midwest, comes from the burning of coal.  That burning releases mercury into the atmosphere where it can be breathed, end up in the waterways, and end up in plant life.  Those who live closest to these plants run risks of exposure in everyday life than those of us who use CFL do as long as we take care.  The second concern from CFL has to do with the ultraviolet (UV) light that comes from them.  Normally, a coating on the bulb protects us from the UV radiation, but in the "corkscrew" shaping, the coating may become chipped and open pathways for the UV radiation to escape.  It is important to make sure that bulbs are not place in situations where a person may be within three feet of the bulb.  In addition, bulbs can now be purchased with a "double casing" with a more standard surface shape to help protect.  The exposure is no greater than the risk of going outside without sunscreen (and significantly lower unless you spend multiple hours sitting next to a completely uncovered CFL), and is also easily managed.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Daily Decisions: How did I get here?






Throughout 2013, Adding Light will take a look at practical decisions that everyone can take to contribute to making our communities more ecologically and economically resilient. Everything in this Daily Decisions comes from experience or research applied directly by our family or people we know directly.

Tonight, I took a tap class for the first time in almost a decade, and it felt great.  Although there is a "feed your soul" sort of personal quality of life moment associated with doing this, my decision today had to do with how to get to the class.  Let's look at my three main options for this kind of commute and see how the balance of quality of life compared with the economic and ecological impact.

Starting point:  my house on the Southside of Chicago
Ending point:  the Fine Arts Building on Michigan Avenue
Event time:  6:00 p.m. to 7:15 p.m.

Option 1:  Drive
Departure time = 5:10 p.m. (25 minute drive + 5 minutes parking and walking to car)
Return time = 7:45 p.m. (20 minute drive + 10 minutes leaving, walking and retrieving car)
Total miles travelled = about 30 miles
Cost per mile = $0.35-0.45 (in my 2001 Toyota Prius)
Parking = $5.00 - $18.00 (street vs. garage)
Total cost of trip = $15.50 - $31.50
Gasoline used = 0.78 gallons (the Prius gets about 38 mpg in winter)
CO2 emissions = approximately 7 kg (8.92 kg/gallon per EPA)
Activities in transit = listening to music, sports radio, or news

Option 2: CTA (103rd St bus to the 95th Red Line Station; transfer to Red Line to Jackson)
Departure time = 4:25 p.m. (10 min. wait + 10 min. bus + 5 min. wait + 45 min. train + 5 min. walk)
Return time = 8:35 p.m. (same travel + 5 minute leaving event)
Total miles travelled = about 30 miles (9 by bus, 21 by heavy rail)
Total cost of trip = $5.00 ($2.50 each way including transfer)
CO2 emissions = approximately 4 kg (using values from Figures 2 and 3 in this DOT document)
Activities in transit = reading online magazines, texting friends and family, doing crosswords, reading

Option 3: Metra (Rock Island Line to LaSalle Street Station)
Departure time = 4:20 p.m. (10 min. walk + 30 min. train + 5 min. walk...last train for event was 4:30)
Return time = 8:20 p.m. (10 min. leaving/walk + 20 min. wait + 30 min. train + 5 min. walk)
Total miles travelled = about 30 miles (almost all by commuter rail)
Total cost of trip = $7.65 ($3.825 each way)
CO2 emissions = 7.8 kg (using values from the Appendix of this DOT document)

Given the options above, I chose Option 3.  I did not choose it because it was the most environmentally friendly way to travel, nor because it was the least expensive.  I chose it because it combined the cost effectiveness with the reliability.  On Option 2, those times heavily depend on the frequency of operation and could vary significantly, especially on the return trip.  For Option 1, traffic could have held me up, but in general, I would spend less time in transit, but at a significant cost.  It should be noted that the environmental performance of my single-occupancy vehicle travel is heavily influenced by the car I would have chosen to drive.  If I had driven a mini-van or SUV getting less than half of the gas milage, I would have had more than twice the environmental impact and slightly greater cost.  All in all, there is no perfect solution to the question right now.  If we can shift vehicle travel to all electric vehicles, that still does not improve the cost of parking or owning a vehicle.  Lastly, the per passenger mile data that feeds into this analysis comes from current ridership, which is under capacity.  Performance would be improved greatly if more people used the service.

This analysis can be done (and in the future I will revisit it) for many different types of trips.  What makes sense for one type of travel (in this case, short duration event travel), may not make sense for others.

Friday, July 20, 2012

Friday Five: July 20, 2012

Do we really need apocalyptic consequences to take action?
Wildfires ignite debate on global warming
"For some, climate change will become a fact only when its effects hit close to home. For this reason, perhaps we should expect an awareness of the need to adapt to climate change to precede a wider commitment to mitigating climate change itself. If that is the case, reporters are, finally, asking the right questions."

Do so few of us really care that we threaten our future with inaction?
Why Do Generation X Americans Not Care About Climate Change?
"Sociologist Jon Miller, the study's author, sees this as a sign of victory for the climate disinformation campaign. "I was optimistic beacuse this group of people is more scientifically literate; they've grown up in an era of of science and quantitative discussion, unlike their grandparents," Miller says. But the complexity of climate science, the long time scale it takes to play out, and seeds of doubt sown on the nightly news have caused many Gen Xers to simply tune it out."

The fact is: we can develop an energy system with no harmful emissions that is 100% renewably based within 20 years, and reach a 50% level in 10....while growing our economy.
Why do ‘experts’ always lowball clean-energy projections?
"Every time there’s a new air or water regulation proposed, industry predicts a level-10 economic apocalypse. EPA counters by saying it will only be a level-5 economic apocalypse. Invariably, it’s a level-0 economic apocalypse — low costs, lots of lives saved. Yet the political class approaches each new regulation with a peculiar Zen-like no-mind, as though it is the first such argument and all perspectives are equally supported by past experience. Same with projections of energy efficiency and renewables."

It will take some policy level decisions....
Illinois Net Metering Law Helps Grow Residential and Small Business Solar Energy Systems
“The net metering law Governor Quinn signed leads the way to more solar energy development in Illinois,” said Howard Learner, Executive Director of the Environmental Law & Policy Center (ELPC). “It provides a common-sense, economic incentive for businesses and homeowners to invest in solar and small-scale wind power systems.”

And some simple choices at home.
Cooking On The Sunny Side: How Solar Chefs Put Food On The Table
"McArdle lost power at her home in Arlington, Va., for four days during the infamous 'Snowpocalypse' that hit the Northeast in 2010. Fortunately, the retired Foreign Service officer had multiple solar cookers in her house from training sessions she had done in Afghanistan and the U.S."

Happy Friday!