Showing posts with label quality of life. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quality of life. Show all posts

Thursday, October 2, 2014

Does our future depend on a lone genius or collaborative discovery?

As part of a recent discussion with some friends, we debated whether truly groundbreaking innovation comes from the inspired individual working either alone or in complete control of the process, or whether a group of collaborative individuals can produce better results. It is an interesting dilemma to consider. On the one hand, I have witnessed that in problem-solving situations, groups of students and workers almost always get to a more elegant solution faster as a group than individually. That said, our understanding of motion and higher mathematics comes from Newton. The nuclear age rests on the shoulders of Einstein and Niels Bohr. All of our modern electrical systems owe their existence to Faraday and Tesla. In order to start to understand whether there is an answer to this question, I decided to take a look at some of the most important advances in human history and categorize them as to whether they were the result of a "genius" or whether they came through planned or accidental collaboration. The results are interesting.














I want to note that the list of advances comes from an Atlantic article from the end of last year. I do not hold it up as the singular list, but it contained most of the advances I would have expected. After the top eight, I think that the ordering is somewhat irrelevant, but other than the top ten, my analysis did not pay much attention to order. Also, as I looked into each issue, I did not do a full historiography of the topic, but looked at a source or two to get an idea. If the source unequivocally mentioned a person as the inventor or discoverer, then I took that for now. If the source mentioned several people who input or made no immediate mention of an individual, I took that for collaboration.


As a process story, although some fit very easily into one category or another (such as electricity or the Internet), many required a bit of discernment. Most notably, determining whether something was a true collaboration or a series of work by lone authors. I separated one from the other based upon whether the first, last, or major advancement was of a lone author or resulted from a collaboration (even if it is a collaboration through reading the writings of others). Not surprisingly to me, the top four and six of the top ten were the result of lone geniuses.

Next, for some of the older developments, it was impossible to know if some one individual had invented the technology or made the discovery, or whether it took shape over hundreds of years with the input or many. On the other hand, although people like Bell, Tesla, Ford, and Pasteur had labs or staff that performed functions for them to advance the work, I considered those individual achievements as long as there was no evidence that another participated as an equal in the discovery. Admittedly, these are not exact analyses, but my guess is that any inaccuracy created by the former is matched by the inaccuracy in the latter, and will not significantly affect the overall result.

Lastly, before discussing the overall picture, it should be noted that some of the names mentioned previously: Newton, Einstein, Bohr, and some other geniuses of science and mathematics (Planck, Bernoulli, Clausius, Descarte, Kepler, Kelvin, Hooke) do not appear on the list although their scientific discoveries certainly led in part to many of the listed discoveries.

The overall result is that about half came from collaborative ventures, and about half came from "lone genius" efforts. One one side, it appears that advances of high value - the printing press, green revolution, and communications - all came from works of genius, while destructive ones - gun powder, oil drilling and refining, paper money - came from collaborative work. That oversimplifies greatly because although the green revolution allowed us to feed the world, it also expanded populations greatly - a burden we have yet to understand how to handle. Also, sanitation systems and anesthesia have had some of the greatest impacts on the length and quality of life of anything on the list, and they came from collaborative efforts.

One thing that does strike me is the absence of individual scientific or technological achievement in since around 1950. As populations have grown, and educated, developed populations continue to expand, the "lone genius" has lost some value. We still celebrate Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, and even Mark Zuckerberg...but we do so more for their personality than for their individual technical achievement. We see them as the genius among geniuses that garnered the publicity, but rarely do we want to elevate them to the status of a Newton or Einstein.

I wonder if this reluctance is a matter of the time we live in or a reflection on the past. Do we have no more Newtons or Einsteins because they never really existed in the first place...perhaps they are just products of history? Or can a Newton or Einstein not get voice in this modern cacophony where achievements of comfort and entertainment get greater praise than achievements that truly improve quality of life or move science forward. In the past, science was the work largely of the wealthy who had the resources and education to devote time to the endeavor. Since Faraday, we have opened science more to all. In doing so, however, the work becomes separated from those who have the platform to publish and promote.

The ultimate answer to the question has a significant impact on public policy. Should we be providing outlets for those with true aptitude for excellence in science and technology, and give them the freedom to pursue thought and exploration? Or should we continue to funnel resources to large institutions and corporations where collaboration mitigates risk of not finding a solution to a particular problem? We currently have no public policy incentive to develop the next true geniuses, and given that many of the advances that have provided us the quality of life we currently enjoy have come from those geniuses of the past, perhaps we need to think about letting the pendulum (discovered by Galileo) swing back toward cultivating freedom of thought.















Thursday, September 25, 2014

#TBT: Corporations are not people, but they might be drug lords

I live in Chicago, and we have come under national scrutiny for the high homicide rates that have continued in some of the areas of our city. Having lived here all my life, I know the city is much safer than it has ever been, but I also see that some areas continue to struggle with gang violence related largely to the trafficking of illegal drugs. In the same vein, we hear of the troubles in the Mexican border towns where drug cartels move their products. In both these cases, and other similar situations, we have people trying to live their daily lives under the specter of risk posed by the presences of businesses operating outside the law.

And then I read Tim Dickinson's brilliantly written but troubling account of the history behind Koch Industries and how they grew their wealth and turned it into a powerful platform from which to create more wealth and protect their interests. From everything within the article, it became abundantly clear that the only difference between the actions of the various businesses related to Koch Industries and the actions of the street gangs and cartels of the drug business....

Is that gang members go to jail or get killed when they kill people...the Kochs just get richer.

[NTSB] Photo of explosion that killed two teens in Texas in
 1996. The explosion was the result of a poorly maintained
pipeline
Reading the details of the piece - much of it garnered from the Koch's own words, details of court cases against them, whistle-blower reports, and as much information about a private company as can be garnered from FOIA requests to governments with which they deal - it becomes abundantly clear that the Kochs consider human life to have a finite value that gets figured into the equation of how to run their business. Unlike, say a person, who would lose their freedom, property, and any hope of continuing on in a normal existence, if the business practices of the Koch's cause someone to die (which they have) or shorten the lives of another (which they have) or cause irreparable harm to a community (which they have) it is simply a part of doing business. A person's life is only worth what they are likely to get in a lawsuit against the company. The value of a community is only worth what they might have to pay in fines for clean up. This kind of capital-centered capitalism follows the same thinking of the Capone operation and today's gangs.

Yet, we as a society celebrate people like the Kochs and (rightly) seek to imprison the drug gangs. We place this value on business "excellence" but only to the point where someone might end up holding a gun to our face. If our truck gets blown up because a pipeline leaked, that's an accident, even if the "accident" came from the deliberate negligence of a business leader. Because the decision that lead to the death was a business one, that somehow makes it ok in our book.

It is not ok.

We need to have much less tolerance than we do for people's lives being subject to their value on a balance sheet. At the turn of the 20th century, it was conservatives who understood that unbridled capitalism will devalue human life, the environment that supports that life, and the social structures that join us as people...all the things that give us high quality of life. It is no coincidence that once we understood that and put safeguards in place, we enjoyed the greatest growth in lifespan, quality of life, and social equity yet experienced in human civilization.

And then we blew it.

Today, and really since the 1970s, we have allowed morally bankrupt capitalists to tell us what society values. We have allowed them to control more of our economic capital, given them the keys to own our political system, and placed our lives in their hands by the choices we have made. We have - on the whole - accepted the line that business is always good and regulation always bad. Our political system has decided that money is speech, and those with more money get to say more, and that by virtue of their attainment of wealth, they have earned that privilege. We have been wrong, and we need to stop treating people like the Kochs as valued men of high achievement, and call them what they really are...

Criminals.

The outrage against violence in my city should be equal to the outrage we cast on men like the Kochs. Anyone who trades human life for their own gain should end up in prison and not on the cover of business magazines. Until we start holding the people within corporations to the standards we ask of people in general, we will never reach the just, equitable, and peaceful society that our Constitution holds as our nation's aspiration.

Those who operate both legally and morally in our country's economy should - and often do, at least as far as I see - have disdain for the actions of people like the Kochs. Regulation, when properly applied as it is most of the time, provides a transparent description of the marketplace that we the people regard as equitable and of value to us as a country. Requiring those who pipe flammable products across the country to maintain their infrastructure at the highest level of safety is not an onerous and superfluous requirement...it recognizes that selling something while killing people is wrong. Requiring that those who speculate in a commodities market have the capital on hand to back their gamble is not totalitarian domination, it is common sense that every casino in the country follows. Asking our business leaders to comport themselves with the same moral approach that we ask of every single member of our society is not an anti-business philosophy...

It is a pro-people philosophy.

We need our capitalism to be more person-centered and less profit-centered. The modern manner of executing capitalism has not found a manner for the system to value people, so we turn to regulation. With the market completely manipulatable by business, the consumer can usually only demand change in drastic circumstances...and even then only if an independent media draws attention to the matter, and government calls those responsible to the carpet, and almost always only after many people  have been killed. It is up to us whether or not this is acceptable. If you do not find it acceptable, then make noise...with what you purchase, with how you vote, with where you spend your time...in every conceivable way, make some noise.

Kudos to Tim Dickinson and Rolling Stone for putting the truth in print. I only wish I could shake the feeling that a large portion of our population will not read the piece and see it for how it gives a glimpse into the consequences of unbridled, morally corrupt capitalism, but will celebrate the Kochs for what they have done.

Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Valuing labor and leisure

I think that we have the order of summer holidays almost perfect. It is absolutely right that we honor those who have given their lives to protect the right of self-determination for all people, and I personally extend my Memorial Day thoughts to those first responders who have also sacrificed their lives to protect the lives of others. The giving of ones life to protect others sits high in value in any civilization. In the middle of the summer, we recognize the value of thought, and how organizing principles can bring people together. Independence Day in the US is more than just a statement about freedom or quality of life (look at Canada, they have freedom and high quality of life and never fired a shot in independence). The simple statement that every person had equal standing in society stood against almost every successful civilian organization of people since the dawn of agriculture. For those individuals who said it in the face of death, it is right that we remember and honor their efforts. Then we come to the penultimate celebration of the summer, and the one that rightly holds the highest place....

The celebration of labor.

Without labor, no sacrifice or grand statement means anything. Without those who toil, slowly sacrificing their bodies through years of stress and strain, we do not have food on the table, a place to rest our heads, or clean water to drink. Without the struggles of those who have labored previously, we not only would have no infrastructure on which to build our quality of life, but we would not have the concept of the weekend, the virtual elimination of child labor, or the idea that a sick person best serves the market by recovering rather than working themselves to death.

Over the past four decades, there is no question that the great majority of our country, as expressed through the political system, has shown - at best - disrespect, and more likely utter contempt for those who labor. Economically, as a country, we have invested less and less in the productive labor of our own people, and created more and more opportunity for those who work for the accumulation of capital than for those who work to improve the quality of life of people.

Even our economic system devalues the individual who works. We speak of increasing profitability, improving productivity, and chasing efficiency as though they are the greatest accomplishments that we can achieve. Every time we shift capital from production to profit, every increase in productivity, ever efficiency realized means that someone either loses a job, loses wages, or loses freedom. Businesses has no measure of success that seeks to improve the employment of the individual or their access to health and leisure.

This does raise a question, however. Outside of the reasons or intent behind this disrespect toward and devaluation of labor, we need to ask ourselves, how much do we really need to work. As our economy has advanced, little attention has been paid to the thought that as we move toward a more productive economy, that means that we may need to work less. At the turn of the 20th century, almost 12,000,000 people were employed in the agricultural industry...a whopping 16% of the population (not just the workforce). Today, that number sits at around 750,000, or 0.2% of the population. At that same time in history, people died from water outbreaks on a regular basis as we rapidly urbanized our population. Today, approximately 50,000 workers in the water and sewage industry keep us supplied with safe drinking water and separate us from harmful waste. Less than 1% of our population keeps us fed and watered. Since air is free, that means that three out of four of our basic requirements can now be met with almost no labor input.

The last need, shelter, has a more complicated story to tell. Of the entire construction/service workforce of 10 million, it is difficult to separate out how many work directly in the building of residential shelter or support the water and food industries. Some estimate residential construction at as many as 2.5 million, but it is probably safe to say that around 3 to 4 million work directly or indirectly at supporting these basic human needs. Even at that number, and assuming 50 hours of labor a week for each of those individuals, the amount of time each American needs to work in order to maintain the basic necessities of life is about one hour per year.

Although this assessment does not include education or healthcare, it points toward the fact that our efforts to improve quality of life have succeeded. The idea that we have to labor and work hard to provide a basic quality of life no longer holds. We can move away from an economy that seeks to punish us with work, and move toward one in which we all maximize our potential. We will still need farmers, construction workers...labor of all sorts, but in this future, those who sacrifice some of their freedom to pursue those endeavors will receive appropriate compensation for it. We will value labor more highly precisely because we will need to fewer people to do it, and will need to entice those who do away from other pursuits.

Each Labor Day, I thank those who have shortened their lifespan by choosing to use their strength to support a high quality of life for all. More importantly, I hope for a future in which we recognize that we all can work less and still enjoy that quality of life. I look toward a future where the celebration of Labor Day, like the celebration of Memorial Day or Independence Day, recognizes the past sacrifices of a small number so that the larger population can work toward the improvement of our species, and not just its mere survival.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

A practical case for reconsidering GMO based on taste

Let me be the first to call myself out: I am not a food science expert.  I am a mechanical engineer with a good background in energy systems, construction, and building design.  I have a fairly decent knowledge of communications systems, economics, and quantum physics.  I am above average in my knowledge of theater, 80s pop/rock, and almost every competitive sporting activity.  But I am not a food science expert, so take the rest of this post with the proverbial grain of salt…

The food in England and France tastes better than the food in the US.

This is not an American self-loathing thing…I really love our country.  Despite several flaws, it's a great place to live, and we have an unwavering hope that things will get even better.  This is not saying that food in America is awful, just that the food in England and France tastes better.

Last month, my wife, my oldest child, and I spent some time in Paris and London.  We are not entirely normal tourists, as we like to trek off the beaten path and get into the neighborhoods of cities we visit.  Our meals do not consist of hitting the most highly rated restaurants in major cities, so my taste comparisons cover the standard fare.  We bought groceries at a standard corner store in London for our breakfasts and snacks, grabbed meals at neighborhood pubs and restaurants for most of our meals, and even sampled a cart vendor or two along the way.  At each turn, even in the highly Americanized sports pub, the food had a richer quality of taste to it.  I am not making claims that it was better for us, just that on the quality of taste, there was a noticeable difference compared with American food.

This is where my observation turns to supposition.  In talking with people over there, and having read about food systems in the UK and mainland Europe, there are two striking differences.  First, much of the food systems are inherently local.  There are certainly South American bananas, but most of the staple crops come from farms within the country…which comparatively would mean within the geographic area of our states.  This short farm-to-table timeframe could easily account for much of the heightened flavor in the food.  Second, European countries practice the precautionary principle.  That means that anything consumed by people must be proven safe prior to consumption.  They have heavy restrictions on food additives, GMO, and processing.  There is still much debate about the safety of food additives, and especially GMO, but little of that discussion has included quality.  A completely unscientific analysis suggests to me that it would help to include it in the discussion.  Lastly, the portion sizes are drastically different.  In the states, we are fine with average tasting food if the portion gives us the quality to match our payment.  Perhaps in Europe, the smaller portion size forces vendors to ensure that the quality of the food matches the customers expectations of value.

Sometimes, our debates in this country become more about the debating than the topic.  We have talked for the better part of the last decade about the food industry from the point of view of safety, energy intensity, and environmental damage.  This brief sampling suggests to me that we should provide equal footing to the quality of the food, and not just look at food as a business, but something that sustains life in myriad ways.


Monday, March 31, 2014

How to solve the problem of fossil fuels in fewer than 100 years.

Last week, I had a reunion of sorts with several colleagues whom I met during graduate school.  Among the pleasant conversations about family and work, we got onto the topic of fossil fuel energy and its place in our world.  As we all met working on "green energy" projects, we all agreed on the need to get away from fossil fuels, but disagreed on the timeframe.  One friend noted it would be one hundred years before we were able to eliminate them from the bulk of our economy, and challenged me to come up with the actions I would take if I had all the capital and power in the world to make them happen.  I considered the question for most of the week, and came up with the following:

1.  Buy up all leases for fossil fuel deposits, all American public utilities, and all the aging fossil fuel reliant infrastructure and capital.
Sunk costs for electricity-generating assets and infrastructure, as well as the expected profits associated with future development of fossil fuels weigh heavily on the economics of switching to an efficient and renewable future for energy.  The next great financial bubble will come from the over-valuation of the carbon resources in the earth, resulting in another potential - and perhaps even more devastating - market correction.  The need to recover sunk costs puts a cyclical burden on the transition to a green energy future.  First, we prolong the use of the infrastructure in order to allow the utility to make back its investment with a guaranteed return, then we make complementary investments in infrastructure that works with the existing in order to meet growth.  We need to break both of these cycles in order to move forward at a rapid enough pace.  In addition, I would buy up all the used parts and pieces I could, disassemble them into their constituent parts, and repurpose the raw materials for green energy development.

2.  Reissue the resource and utility leases as a package deal, with a twist.
In order to continue the services that the utilities facilitate, but with a minimum of damage to human health, I would auction off the leases to fossil fuels, but link them (by energy content) to management of a utility.  This would link production and performance.  Then, I would restructure the utility in two ways.  One, the utility would provide the end service (i.e. heat, light, access to entertainment) instead of energy.  Customers would pay for the service instead of the units of energy, and thus reward those who provide the best end result, not the ones whom they are forced to pay.  Then, at the end of each year, these new utilities would receive a bonus payment based upon the amount of resource remaining in the ground.  They would not only increase profitability by using fewer resources in efficiently delivering services, they would receive incentive payments for leaving more of the carbon resources in the earth.

3.  Carbon tax to meet the real cost of using the energy and eliminate all subsidies.
The mining, transporting, processing, transferring, and eventual releasing of energy associated with fossil fuels has myriad negative impacts, and currently receive almost $700 billion in worldwide subsidies.  Currently, the fossil fuel industry only pays direct costs (transportation, storage, processing) but does not pay for ecological restoration of mined areas, healthcare costs for those located near combustion sites, property damage associated with polluted air, or other similar indirect costs.  To start with, we would end any subsidy to a fossil-fuel based company, using the money to subsidize a transition for those who cannot immediately afford the increased costs that might result from the end of that subsidy.  Then, each year, the insurance industry would determine the tax level based upon the reinsurance costs for each of the indirect impacts.  Governments would collect the tax to continue to provide the services they do to make up for the slight from industry, and would offset the new tax collected by lowering the overall income tax to balance.  Companies could lower their tax burden by including some of the indirect costs into their direct costs.  They can do this by taking over ecological restoration of mined areas, implementing complete carbon capture and repurposing (the act of preparing the carbon or carbon dioxide for benign storage and reuse in a specific industry...this means no sequestration without a plan for reuse), completely scrubbing exhaust streams for particulates of all size, and reducing waste heat to benign levels.

Tar sands mining area
4.  Require 99.99999% reliability from fossil fuel infrastructure and complete restoration of ecological services.
Currently, we tolerate too many oil spills, coal ash pollution incidents, and mine collapses as "the cost of doing business".  Industries know what they need to do in order to ensure near perfect performance records.  We need, as a society, to expect that they deliver.  In addition, when they complete mining activities or do have an environmental issue, we need to expect the complete restoration of ecological services.

5.  Immediately implement ecological valuation into the world economy.
Perhaps the best way to make sure capital flows to poorer regions of the world without the extractive growth that fueled southeast Asia and continued our damaging ways comes from the concept of ecological valuation.  Scientists and economists working together determine the real-time value of watersheds, forest systems, plains, species, etc., then include that value in a nation's asset sheet.  This would provide incentive for investment and restoration, while providing a mechanism for richer countries to offset their activities by investing in the preservation of existing ecosystems.  This provides the resources for developing economies to increase quality of life without the health sacrifices we had to make.

6.  Capitalize a series of building and loans in each 50-75,000 person community whose investment portfolio carries only energy efficiency and renewable energy projects in that community.
These nearly 5,000 banks would provide the needed capital to drive the shift from extractive energy reliance to neighborhood energy reliance.  The development of local businesses, and the expansion of local manufacturing to meet this demand would build a more resilient economy while improving the quality of life.  The banks would remain independent entities, beholden to shareholders like any bank, with the only restriction being the boundary of their investment region.  They could link their risk through insurance products, or state/regional-government based loan guarantee programs, in order to minimize their exposure.

7.  Provide free college tuition to top students entering the field of clean energy research and development.
Currently, the top students go into the financial sector or into fields associated with the extractive economy.  Fewer enter the fields of medicine or engineering associated with life-supporting activities.  We want the best ideas to prepare us for a future without fossil fuel energy, and need to provide the incentive to get them into those fields.

8.  Place clean-energy-based restrictions on the not-for-profit status of university endowments.
University endowments represent a significant portion of the nations held wealth, and as such, they wield great power.  For the significant benefit they receive from their tax-exempt status, the universities can bear a certain level of restriction over what they can do with those assets.  First, all of them must divest from all fossil-fuel investments.  Second, they must commit one-third of their asset portfolio to clean energy or energy efficiency projects; they choose the ones that maximize their return.  Third, they must make all buildings on all properties that they own net zero impact buildings within a decade; this includes all existing buildings as well as new and recently constructed.  The knowledge base and technology exist to make this happen, and institutions that have a forty to one-hundred year horizon for building ownership have the ability to recoup their investment easily.

9.  Change the current way we discount future life value.
We need to make all energy and quality of life decisions providing equal value to a life seven generations from now as we do to a current life.  We conveniently employ a discount rate that makes positive impacts on the future have to save ten lives to have equal value to saving one life today.  For non-life threatening activities, discounting the future has merit, for it favors conservative allocation of resources.  For activities that damage human health, however, this practice amounts to a death sentence for the future.

10.  Manage a smart transition for developing economies.
In addition to the economic development incentives offered by ecological valuation, we need to provide reasonable support and incentives for the developing world.  Unlike the developed world, these economies cannot easily remove fossil fuels from their quality of life systems.  People in these parts of the world still have underdeveloped fresh water systems, little or no electrification, and must travel great distances for basic needs.  We do not need to enable reliance on fossil fuels for new development, but cannot pull the rug out from under their current way of life.  Pursuing the above strategies will free resources to help manage this process, and ensure that developing economies avoid our pitfalls while raising the quality of life for nearly half of the world's population.  People are resourceful, and right now they are finding the simplest way they can to develop with the most readily available technology.  If we put the right technologies in front of people, they will innovate and find the right solution with the best outcomes.  We do not need to do things for them, but we need to make the right pieces available to them.

The challenge presented to me gave me no limit on my power or wealth, so I have not concerned myself with the economic impact of these activities.  Over the coming months, I will investigate them further and evaluate the costs and benefits of them.  We need to pursue these, and all other ideas for realizing a clean energy future, with a great sense of urgency.  We do not have the one-hundred years my friend conjectures we need to fully transition.  From this point forward, we need to stop enabling our dependence on fossil fuels merely because it is hard to do otherwise.  We need to expect more of ourselves; we have the knowledge, resources, and ability...now all we need is the will.

Friday, March 28, 2014

Friday Five: March 28, 2014

We hold onto a shaky hope that the use of fossil fuels to power our lives has little to no consequence on our quality of life. The truth is far more certain: our reliance on fossil fuels harms our lives, albeit unequally. For those with the means to live far from threatened areas near mines, power plants, and waste facilities, life goes along without complaint. For those not so lucky, they at best lead a life that is less healthy, and at worst die younger than those more fortunate.
When the rivers run black
"The result is that the exhaust that emerges today is far cleaner than it was decades ago. But cleaning up the airborne emissions means that the solids remaining after the burn are far dirtier than before. In fact, coal ash is often loaded with arsenic, mercury, lead, and other contaminating elements. A 2012 study published in the journal Environmental Science & Technology found that cleaner air emissions are traded for 'significant enrichments of contaminants in solid wastes and wastewater discharged from power plants.'"

The anti-regulation economist believes that in the absence of regulation, business will always do what is best for quality of life because its customers will demand it do so and business always responds to its customers. Except, that what its customers don't know....
Activists catch power plant on hidden camera
"...a hidden camera set up by the Sierra Club ... shows a power plant regularly discharging coal ash pond water into the Ohio River, apparently permitted via a very liberal interpretation of the meaning of 'occasional.'"

The coal industry requires subsidies to stay profitable. An industry over a century old still needs government help to remain afloat. If you think that to be a bunch of environmentalist lies, here is but one example of the over $650 billion in worldwide subsidies to the fossil fuel industry.
Why are we hauling Pennsylvania coal all the way to Germany?
"'The industry was struggling, and the Pennsylvania delegation wanted to do something to help it,' says Jim Dyer, who today is a lobbyist with the Podesta Group, but began his career four decades ago in the office of Pennsylvania Republican Rep. Joseph McDade. 'The one way it could help it was ... to get the federal government interested in buying some of it.'"

Even with these subsidies, we know that the coal industry - without a game changing technology breakthrough that addresses the myriad health and environmental issues - cannot survive economically. This is not conjecture, but a fact of the marketplace.
Pacific Power's reliance on coal sends Oregonians' electricity bills soaring
"The OPUC hearing comes in light of Sierra Club’s analysis of reports from the Edison Electric Institute (EEI) showing that Oregon Pacific Power customers have seen their electricity bills increase by 61% since 2006, the year after Warren Buffet started operating the utility. Pacific Power customers saw a greater rate increase than customers of any other major utility in the six states that Pacific Power serves. The costs of continuing to operate old, outdated coal plants continue to rise, and Pacific Power’s parent company, PacifiCorp, will seek rate recovery from Oregon customers for its $4.2 billion coal fleet expenditures. PacifiCorp owns the largest number of coal plants in the West, and Pacific Power customers in Oregon get 63% of their energy from out-of-state coal plants."
Goldman Sachs declares solar energy will soon be cheaper than fossil fuels, and Elon Musk is a genius
"'…our Clean Energy team believes the number of households hitting grid parity will continue to grow as the cost of the systems comes down … SolarCity has seen a 40% decline in the per watt cost of PV panels since the second quarter of 2013 driven by improved scale which is expected to continue,' state clean tech analysts Brian Lee and Thomas Daniels. 'This has been true for Tesla’s battery costs as well, which have declined from of $500/KWh in 2008 to $250/KWh for the Model S to potentially $125/KWh at the gigafactory. As a result we should note that the quantitative grid parity and return calculations we show above are arrived at without any Federal or state credits.'"

This past winter showed us that fossil fuel electricity generation has intermittency issues on par with those of wind and solar. That does not mean that we should trade one intermittency for another (although the environmental costs should force that decision on us), but we should solve the issue regardless of energy source chosen. Batteries will not solve the problem, and although hydro and flywheels have promise, I like simple solutions. This one is "in the book" as Paul Erdos might say.
Energy storage hits the rails out west
"Compared to the mechanics of chemical batteries, the idea behind rail storage is simple. During periods of low electricity demand, power is dispatched from the nearby grid to pull a chain of weighted train cars uphill. And there they will sit—losing no power to degradation—until the grid has a period of high power demand. Then they are sent rolling downhill. Their momentum sends electrons back to the grid through a system of regenerative braking that uses the turning power of the wheels to generate electricity."

Happy Friday!

Friday, March 14, 2014

Friday Five: March 14, 2014

All the arguments about climate change and carbon dioxide emissions ignores another great challenge of fossil fuel pollution, and one that industry has yet to find an adequate solution for: fine particulate matter.  The unburned, solid carbon creates a whole host of health issues, and left unaddressed, it will continue to plague us.
New research shows air pollution might make you bad at your job
"What they found was that every 10-microgram per cubic meter increase in PM2.5 levels decreased worker productivity by 0.6%, as measured by the number pear boxes packed by each worker. Since workers were paid piecemeal, this translated to a decrease of roughly 41 cents per hour, per 10 micrograms of PM2.5."

The urban pollution caused largely by automobile emissions, but also by industrial activity and building heating, leads to consequences that affect our nations poor and people of color at rates higher than that of other population groups.
Dyin' to live: Biggie Smalls and the silent killers in urban America
"Cancer and heart disease are still the top causes for premature deaths in Brooklyn today. Environmental factors have long been suspected as possible causes for both. The National Cancer Institute conducted a study in the 1990s in Long Island (just north of Brooklyn) to examine the role of environmental factors in the high breast cancer rates in that area. The researchers found a “modest increase” in cancer risk due to exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), cancer-causing agents formed mostly from burning fossil fuels. A 2008 study found a link between PAH exposure and heart disease, and concluded that “chronic environmental stress is an important determinant” in cardiovascular disease risk."

Over the last several years, I have called for a planned, stable transition from utilities of infrastructure to utilities of service.  In order for utilities to survive, they have to make that transition, and it looks like in the nations on the forefront of renewable energy, that transition has started...to a point.
The future of large German utilities: It's already here
"If I would have written this paper two years ago and included the following, I would have called it utopia. Nobody would have believed it. But this unbelievable story actually happened. These four large German utilities decided to become 'green.' This can be seen from their recent advertisements, which show that all of the four major German utilities are 'solarized.'"

Making change that has lasting economic impact requires correctly identifying the value of the improvement and working that into the business plan of those developing, improving, or refurbishing.  Many homeowners and developers avoid improvements with long-term benefits because they cannot monetize those in the present.  A system that correctly values the improvements - and holds developers especially accountable for their performance - provides the proper incentive to make choices that improve quality of life. 
How to help appraisers fairly value home energy efficiency improvements
"Nothing works in the appraisal process unless high performance homes are consistently documented. Right now, the majority of home appraisers use Fannie Mae’s Uniform Residential Appraisal Report to provide opinions on the market value of a given property. But, this form lacks an adequate section in which to document energy efficiency features."

Economics can produce poor decisions.  The economics of developing, maintaining, and decommissioning nuclear energy do not really work, and the risk of catastrophe only exacerbates the point.  That said, in a nation whose economy depends on a fixed level of energy cost, it is tempting to go back to it...even when it has already damaged your country and its people.
Nuclear power in Japan: Start 'em up
"The sense of urgency is driven, first, by the mounting costs of doing without the nuclear plants. One by one, nearly all reactors were shut down in 2011-12. Utilities fired up conventional power stations to make up for lost electricity generation. But the cost of importing extra oil, coal and gas has been all the steeper with a weak yen. The trade deficit has climbed, along with electricity charges, particularly for businesses. Should nuclear plants be left idle, the programme of Shinzo Abe, the prime minister, to revive the economy could be in doubt."

Happy Friday!